
It’s impossible to ignore, but I’ve gotten really good at it most of the time. Valentine’s Day. So prevalent, that there’s alternatives (Galentine’s and Palentine’s are what come to mind).
I don’t know how much I want to divulge about my history with romance. I hate the idea of unintentionally publicly demonizing anyone when I know there’s never a purely one-sided failure.
… You know what, I’ll touch on a few things vaguely so there’s an understanding of where I’m coming from.
When I was a little kid, I was a weird little girl. I had big ideas about the world, including idealized notions of romance. I had crushes all the way back to kindergarten; but mostly it was me wanting to emulate crushes and romance I would see in cartoons and TV. I didn’t necessarily have a good role model growing up for what “real healthy romance” was until I was maybe 7 or 8 years old, and by then I don’t think I trusted any real people to be good and faithful.
But by golly, did I “love” hard. I put “love” in quotations because as we all know, anything before 18 years old doesn’t count as real love. You’re just learning before then. I sound like I’m being facetious but truly I don’t have a specific age or instance where it clicked into place. I latched onto people and idealized what could have been, and sometimes these crushes would last for years.
My first relationship was when I was still a little girl, technically, if we go by labels. It was my best friend, and I’d loved him for years; probably since I moved to my little village in Upstate NY. We were only like 11, and that clearly didn’t get far, but I wouldn’t feel resentful about all that until many years later when we were friends again. I did a lot wrong over many years with him, but ultimately I should have let us drift apart when it naturally happened. I think I held on and tried again because somewhere I never lost sight of the one I’d fallen in love with as a kid, when both of us were much different than the two kids we’d once been, running around in the woods and our backyards pretending to be in Naruto or Pokemon. We both changed so much. In fact, I’m a guy now. Funny how that works.
Thinking of my teen years, things were complicated and messy. I had an online “boyfriend” who I never knew exactly who he really was– I’d met him on Gaiaonline, writing Pokemon forum-based roleplays together. He was the first example of me falling for people for no other reasons but creative similarities and Nice To Me. I called that the Hakumei Effect (because that was his handle on the site) for years.
Then from I’d say late-8th-grade through to right about when I graduated high school, I had an on-again, off-again situation with a boy I was very willing to go Romeo and Juliet with for a number of those years. I was unstable, for sure. I just wanted a fairytale romance, and I was deeply delusional and volatile about it. I don’t blame him for trying to pull away so often. I even wonder if I’d apologize to him for those 5 years if I had the chance. And again, under 18 doesn’t count tooooo much, so I can’t even be like “he shouldn’t have cheated and then insisted on an open relationship about it” because honestly I wouldn’t have been rational about it even if he approached me with a level head.
I was perpetuating a cycle I never wanted to. My mom got into many awful publicly-undisclosable situations because she was trying to have a fulfilling romance when I was young, and I in turn subconsciously repeated the patterns I’d taken in but as an undiagnosed teenager.
The open relationship definitely opened exactly one door for me. As a youth, part of my issue was being undesirable. I should have let that be. When you’re a teenager and focused on being wanted, you open a particular door.
When I was about 17, I met a guy online. That guy was 26 years old.
I remember mentally trying to justify it even to myself. Well, 17 was the age of consent in New York, so clearly it was fine. He always asked for inappropriate photos but clearly that meant he wanted me, right? I think that lasted a good 5 months; towards the end, he started saying stuff like “I have a heart condition, and if I get stressed I could die” which kept me around longer than I had felt comfortable doing so.
Then at 18, I was dumped from my main squeeze right around when I graduated. But hey! That meant I could go to college and experience wild college life, right?
I had several crushes, I fell hard and fast very often. None of them panned out. At all. There was clearly something wrong with me– I was going to parties and having fun otherwise, but I’d walk back to my dorm alone (or later in the 4 years, I’d walk back with my roommate, since we went to many of the same parties) and wonder what was wrong with me. Some confessions were handled well enough, while some became so uncomfortable they’d avoid me altogether after that point.
Can I blame any of that on me being pre-transition and therefore hating myself for not meeting some expectation I had imposed on myself to be “woman” right? Maybe. I think I started questioning and experimenting with my gender when I was 21 or 22. Undertale transed my gender (kidding. Probably).
The rejections were anywhere from “You’re a wonderful person and a great friend, and I don’t feel the same but I want the best life for you and I think you can do so much better than me” to “I like skinnier girls” to complete ghosting. The latter two I was pretty used to by that point. The first example was surprising to me and I hold that memory very dear to myself simply because it was someone I’d admired for a couple years and he managed to let me down nicely.
From 2013 to 2022 I was completely single. I didn’t understand what was wrong with me, I went on a total of one (1) mutual date before the 2020 debacle and that guy made me feel like I was just fetish fuel.
I met someone in 2022. They introduced me to something I’d only heard of vaguely before– queerplatonic relationships. Something defined purely by the people involved. Something clicked for me then, and I decided to loosely try it out for at least a while. I admire this person, y’know? We only know each other online, but we have a lot in common and I enjoy talking to them, so why not make it special? It wasn’t romance. It felt good being close to someone without needing the romantic label.
Then in 2023 I met another someone. Technically I met a bunch of someones, but like, I only romanced one. I tried with a different one of that bunch of someones but we figuratively shook hands and went “probably not”.
The one who did pursue romance with me finally taught me what I needed to understand from the 10 years of reflection up to that point– I can’t handle being romantically involved. With anyone. I’m not broken, like as a person, but if romance were a bone, it would have been broken and set and healed wrong.
At first it was nice to have someone to call mine the way I’d always wanted. I was still loosely involved with my qpr, but I considered myself taken with this boyfriend of mine.
That was a mistake.
I cannot do romance.
It started out so nicely. I loved this long distance boyfriend of mine. But suddenly he was my fiance and future co-parent for children we’d raise together and I felt my autonomy slipping away and it was my fault. I was falling back into the bad patterns I’d learned before. I needed to be his everything, and I can’t be anyone’s everything. I started tearing myself apart because I couldn’t fix all his problems, and all the while he was planning a big wedding and I never wanted children but I kept agreeing because he loved me and that’s what love was; sacrificing and codependency.
Between catching myself in that codependent spiral and continued pushing and breaking of my boundaries, I did something I never thought I’d do–
I left.
I never thought I’d have it in me to willingly leave anyone. I’m the master of the Irish Goodbye in social settings, sure, but I was raised to be unerringly loyal to people I cared about.
I was then accused of never caring at all.
After over at least a hundred dollars sent to him over the course of 2 years, after video calls as I was recovering from top surgery, after letting him propose at 3 months when I’d tried telling him to wait a year…
I had allowed all that to happen because I wanted it to work so bad. I wanted to finally have a romance with someone who wanted me with no ulterior motives.
…
So now, about a year after breaking that off, where am I at and what am I thinking?
My queerplatonic relationship continues. In fact, I’ve loosely associated myself with a few people. There’s four of us working together to heal from the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune. I may just be tagging along for all I know, but we all seem to love each other… just, not romantically, you know?
I may never be able to be anyone’s everything. The others don’t want me to be, as long as none of them have to be my everything in return. And somehow, that works for me better than any romance I’ve tried to pursue.
…
So. Valentine’s Day. I spent years hating it. I spent years feeling resentful of being alone and being undesirable. Valentine’s Day was just a reminder of all that “but hey, at least there’s cheap chocolate”. Too many hearts, too much pink.
Ironically, now that I’m a guy, I think valentine’s hearts and the color palette of the holiday unironically SLAP.
We’re all skittish. We’re all hurt people. Maybe I’m the only one who is coming back around on the holiday so far! But I think we’re going to be okay. We’ll figure it out together, and I’ll be able to keep an eye on my own boundaries easier now that I’m not trying to be perfect for someone. I can only be the best me I can be, and they seem to like it well enough.






















































